Home > Risks Management and Insurance Magazine > Articles > Geoengineering: climate research and risk management

Geoingeniería (1200x410)_vOK

Geoengineering: climate research and risk management

17/11/2026

Climate intervention, better known as geoengineering, is the deliberate alteration of the climate to counteract some effects of global warming. It’s not a solution to climate change, but rather a set of techniques that reduce or offset its impact.

Geoengineering raises issues that go beyond its technical viability. How can we manage the risks of deliberately intervening in such a complex system and how long would we have to do it for? Some proposals could offer a relatively rapid reduction of certain consequences of global warming, but also generate new risks, unequal regional effects, and, in the case of some techniques, a dependence on interventions that would have to be maintained for long periods.

The United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) distinguishes between two main aspects: carbon dioxide removal (CDR), which extracts CO₂ from the atmosphere and stores it durably; and solar radiation modification (SRM), which aims to reduce warming by boosting radiation reflection into space. The scale, purpose, and mechanism of action are essential to distinguish these interventions from other atmospheric weather modification practices.

Limited effect in time and space

Artificially modifying the weather acts on local or regional phenomena and during relatively short periods. The World Meteorological Organization (WMO) lists rain or snow stimulation, hail size reduction, and fog dispersion as weather modification applications. These actions don’t allow us to control the planet’s climate or produce large-scale weather events at will. The WMO points out that “the energy involved in meteorological systems is so great that it’s impossible to create cloud systems that cause rain, alter wind patterns to introduce water vapor into a region, or eliminate extreme weather events.” Therefore, technologies that claim to achieve such drastic or large-scale effects lack a solid scientific base.

However, the practice exists and has operational uses. AEMET, Spain’s national weather service, points out that more than 50 countries carry out artificial time modification activities. In Spain, the Hydraulic Public Domain Regulation establishes that the atmospheric phase of the hydrological cycle can only be artificially modified by the State Administration, or by those authorized by it, and such actions should only be aimed at avoiding rainfall in the form of hail.

The nuance is important: Cloud seeding doesn’t equate to generating rain at will. Its effectiveness depends on the presence of clouds and suitable atmospheric conditions, and the results can vary considerably depending on the type of cloud and weather conditions. The WMO emphasizes that scientific evidence must guide both research and operations.

What techniques are used and what is their scope?

Removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere can be achieved through different geoengineering techniques, including reforestation and soil carbon management, as well as technological options like the direct CO₂ capture and storage. The IPCC considers that carbon removal will play a role in pathways that limit warming, especially to offset residual emissions that are difficult to eliminate. However, it warns of significant differences between methods in maturity, permanence, costs, and impacts on water, food, and biodiversity.

Moreover, not all CRM methods offer the same degree of permanence. The IPCC points out that the carbon stored in vegetation and soils can return to the atmosphere as a result of natural or human disturbances, while geological storage can offer much greater permanence if managed properly.

Solar radiation modification raises a different question. It doesn’t eliminate greenhouse gases, but rather tries to offset part of their thermal effect. Among the proposals studied are the injection of aerosols into the stratosphere or boosting the reflectivity of certain clouds. Modeling studies indicate that these techniques could reduce average global temperatures, but they also show possible unequal regional effects and significant risks and uncertainties. Moreover, it wouldn’t stop the increase in atmospheric CO₂ nor the ocean acidification while emissions continue.

In both cases there is an important territorial issue: any intervention with cross-border effects requires considering who decides, who assumes the risk, and how the potential benefits and damages are distributed. Precisely because of their possible cross-border scope, research on these techniques raises issues of governance, transparency, public participation, and climate justice, and that’s why the World Economic Forum advocates for an ethical, transparent, and inclusive use of these techniques.

Research before intervening

Although geoengineering has been the subject of misinformation and unsupported claims, caution is a constant in much of the scientific literature on these techniques. At the same time, different scientific organizations consider it necessary to investigate its possible benefits, limitations, and risks in order to make informed decisions.

In October 2024, the American Geophysical Union (AGU) published an ethical framework for research on climate intervention based on five principles: responsible research, climate justice, inclusive public participation, transparency, and informed governance. The paper insists that research shouldn’t be presented as an alternative to reducing emissions and points out that the consequences of some large-scale interventions are still not sufficiently well understood.

The situation is, therefore, less sensationalist than some narratives suggest, and more useful than certain skeptical sectors insist. There are techniques to modify the weather that are used on a local scale; methods of removing CO₂ that are already practiced, although with very different capabilities and limitations; and proposals to modify solar radiation that continue to be the subject of research and debate.

More than a tool to control climate, geoengineering is today a heterogeneous set of research and technologies with different degrees of maturity. The main challenge isn’t just to determine what can be done technically, but to understand what the consequences are, who would take responsibility for the risks involved, and under what conditions such practices would be considered acceptable.

donwload pdf
Environmental responsibility: prevent, repair and respond

Environmental responsibility: prevent, repair and respond

Environmental responsibility goes beyond awareness or voluntary commitment. The regulatory framework imposes specific obligations related to prevention, compliance, and repair that make it necessary to integrate environmental management into corporate strategy. An...

read more
Marine insurance: how to evaluate the risk of old ships

Marine insurance: how to evaluate the risk of old ships

The aging Latin American fleet presents specific challenges for hull insurance and requires underwriting criteria that take maintenance, management of the shipowner, and crew experience into account. The age of a given vessel doesn't always reflect its state of...

read more
Submarine cables: invisible arteries of global connectivity

Submarine cables: invisible arteries of global connectivity

Beneath the oceans lies an infrastructure that is critical to the global economy and global communications: submarine cables. They carry most of the international data traffic and must deal with constant technological, economic, and geopolitical challenges. In 2022,...

read more